| . | Charlie Hustle Division |
| . | The other of the two "Original" divisions, the Moonshiners are the only team that has not been exclusively within the division, coming over from the Hammerin' Hank Division in 1997. The Nine was an Expansion team in '95. The Pioneers moved over in 2009 swapping with the Moonshiners, while the Oxen moved over from the Hammerin' Hank Division in 2009 swapping with the San Diego Sluggers. |
| . | West Penn River Rats | ||||||||||||
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | Year | Team | Manager | W | L | Pct | GB | BA | Rk | ERA | Rk | Titles | Playoffs |
| . | 1993 | Orioles | Mike Eliyas | 70 | 92 | .432 | 30 | n/a | - | n/a | - | n/a | n/a |
| . | 1994 | Orioles | Mike Eliyas | 68 | 84 | .418 | 8 | n/a | - | n/a | - | n/a | n/a |
| . | 1995 | Grizzlies | Mike Eliyas | 72 | 90 | .444 | 27 | .268 | 9th | 4.76 | 11th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 1996 | Grizzlies | Mike Eliyas | 96 | 66 | .593 | 2 | .292 | 1st | 3.98 | 5th | Wildcard | Lost World Series |
| . | 1997 | Grizzlies | Mike Eliyas | 93 | 69 | .574 | 7 | .281 | 1st | 4.42 | 9th | Wildcard | Lost in LCS |
| . | 1998 | Grizzlies | Mike Eliyas | 66 | 96 | .407 | 34 | .256 | 12th | 4.90 | 13th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 1999 | Grizzlies | Mike Eliyas | 104 | 56 | .650 | 3 | n/a | - | n/a | - | Wildcard | Won World Series |
| . | 2000 | Grizzlies | Mike Eliyas | 73 | 89 | .451 | 26 | .269 | 13th | 4.66 | 4th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2001 | Blue Crabs | ? | 94 | 68 | .580 | 7 | .274 | 8th | 4.77 | 9th | Wildcard | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 2002 | High Rollers | Gary Bringhurst | 95 | 67 | .586 | 13 | .271 | 7th | 4.48 | 9th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2003 | Lightning | Randy Shreiner | 101 | 61 | .623 | ---- | .266 | 3rd | 3.41 | 2nd | Division Crown | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 2004 | Lightning | Randy Shreiner | 70 | 37 | .654 | 0.5 | .277 | 3rd | 3.39 | 2nd | Wildcard | Won World Series |
| . | 2005 | Lightning | Randy Shreiner | 95 | 67 | .586 | ---- | .271 | 7th | 4.43 | 8th | Division Crown | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 2006 | Blaze | Bill Hoover | 81 | 81 | .500 | 11.5 | ? | ? | ? | ? | Wildcard | Lost in LCS |
| . | 2007 | Pioneers | Daymon Ward | 59 | 103 | .364 | 33 | .241 | 15th | 5.15 | 15th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2008 | Pioneers | Daymon Ward | 79 | 83 | .488 | 15 | .250 | 13th | 4.77 | 10th | Wildcard | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 2009 | Pioneers | Daymon Ward | 79 | 83 | .488 | 8 | .259 | 7th | 5.01 | 13th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2010 | Pioneers | Daymon Ward | 70 | 92 | .432 | 16 | .267 | 6th | 5.58 | 16th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2011 | Pioneers | Daymon Ward | 82 | 80 | .506 | 9 | .000 | -- | 0.00 | -- | Wildcard | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 2012 | River Rats | Brian LeBeck | 86 | 76 | .531 | 9 | .000 | -- | 0.00 | -- | Wildcard | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | Totals | 1633 | 1540 | .515 | 2 Division Titles | 2 Championships | |||||||
| . | 9 Wildcards | 3 LCS Titles | |||||||||||
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | Nashville Nine | ||||||||||||
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | Year | Team | Manager | W | L | Pct | GB | BA | Rk | ERA | Rk | Titles | Playoffs |
| . | 1995 | Wildcats | Robert Endries | 76 | 86 | .469 | 19 | .252 | 13th | 4.27 | 6th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 1996 | Wildcats | Robert Endries | 75 | 87 | .463 | 8 | .241 | 14th | 4.75 | 12th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 1997 | Wildcats | Robert Endries | 92 | 70 | .568 | ---- | .264 | 11th | 3.96 | 4th | Division Crown | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 1998 | Wildcats | Robert Endries | 87 | 75 | .537 | ---- | .250 | 13th | 4.08 | 6th | Division Crown | Lost in LCS |
| . | 1999 | Wildcats | Robert Endries | 77 | 85 | .475 | 25 | n/a | - | n/a | - | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2000 | Wildcats | Robert Endries | 72 | 90 | .444 | 20 | .263 | 16th | 5.57 | 12th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2001 | Wildcats | Robert Endries | 81 | 81 | .500 | 13 | .284 | 1st | 5.73 | 14th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2002 | Wildcats | Robert Endries | 66 | 96 | .407 | 28 | .249 | 15th | 5.12 | 10th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2003 | Wildcats | Robert Endries | 71 | 90 | .441 | 38.5 | .246 | 12th | 4.81 | 12th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2004 | Wildcats | Robert Endries | 55 | 53 | .509 | 16 | .255 | 9th | 4.52 | 8th | Wildcard | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 2005 | Wildcats | Robert Endries | 83 | 79 | .512 | 12 | .274 | 5th | 5.27 | 13th | Wildcard | Lost in LCS |
| . | 2006 | Wildcats | Robert Endries | 86 | 75 | .534 | 7.5 | ? | ? | ? | ? | Wildcard | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 2007 | Nine | Rob Johnson | 67 | 94 | .416 | 30.5 | .232 | 16th | 5.16 | 16th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2008 | Nine | Rob Johnson | 48 | 114 | .296 | 50 | .232 | 16th | 5.84 | 16th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2009 | Nine | Rob Johnson | 87 | 75 | .537 | ---- | .266 | 6th | 4.64 | 11th | Division Crown | Lost World Series |
| . | 2010 | Nine | Rob Johnson | 69 | 93 | .426 | 17 | .251 | 11th | 4.77 | 11th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2011 | Nine | Rob Johnson | 91 | 71 | .562 | ---- | .000 | -- | 0.00 | -- | Division Crown | Lost World Series |
| . | 2012 | Nine | Rob Johnson | 93 | 69 | .574 | 2 | .000 | -- | 0.00 | -- | Wildcard | Lost in LCS |
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | Totals | 1372 | 1483 | .481 | 4 Division Titles | 2 LCS Titles | |||||||
| . | 4 Wildcards | ||||||||||||
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | Chesterton Oxen | ||||||||||||
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | Year | Team | Manager | W | L | Pct | GB | BA | Rk | ERA | Rk | Titles | Playoffs |
| . | 1993 | Lightning | Steve Taylor | 82 | 80 | .506 | 27 | n/a | - | n/a | - | n/a | n/a |
| . | 1994 | Lightning | Steve Taylor | 89 | 73 | .549 | 17 | n/a | - | n/a | - | Wildcard | Won World Series |
| . | 1995 | Lightning | Steve Taylor | 84 | 78 | .519 | 4 | .270 | 8th | 4.57 | 8th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 1996 | Lightning | Steve Taylor | 77 | 85 | .475 | ---- | .266 | 6th | 4.42 | 9th | Division Crown | Lost in LCS |
| . | 1997 | Wahoos 97 | Chris Dail | 84 | 78 | .519 | 12.5 | .274 | 5th | 4.26 | 6th | Wildcard | Lost in LCS |
| . | 1998 | Wahoos 97 | Chris Dail | 102 | 60 | .630 | ---- | .289 | 1st | 3.53 | 1st | Division Crown | Lost World Series |
| . | 1999 | Wahoos 97 | Chris Dail | 82 | 80 | .506 | 27 | n/a | - | n/a | - | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2000 | Mirage | ? | 83 | 79 | .512 | 18 | .282 | 4th | 4.96 | 9th | Wildcard | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 2001 | Pioneers | Chris Conley | 72 | 90 | .444 | 24 | .260 | 13th | 5.15 | 12th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2002 | Cardinals | Joe Maestro | 109 | 53 | .673 | ---- | .278 | 4th | 3.95 | 2nd | Division Crown | Won World Series |
| . | 2003 | Cardinals | Joe Maestro | 103 | 59 | .636 | 2 | .262 | 5th | 4.24 | 8th | Wildcard | Won World Series |
| . | 2004 | Cardinals | Joe Maestro | 52 | 56 | .481 | 16 | .267 | 6th | 4.87 | 12th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2005 | Blue Ox | Kim Hoffman | 78 | 84 | .481 | 14 | .251 | 15th | 5.09 | 12th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2006 | Oxen | Kim Hoffman | 85 | 77 | .525 | ---- | ? | ? | ? | ? | Division Crown | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 2007 | Oxen | Kim Hoffman | 73 | 89 | .451 | 23 | .259 | 13th | 5.13 | 14th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2008 | Oxen | Kim Hoffman | 71 | 91 | .438 | 30 | .250 | 12th | 4.56 | 10th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2009 | Oxen | Kim Hoffman | 58 | 104 | .358 | 29 | .243 | 14th | 5.38 | 16th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2010 | Oxen | Kim Hoffman | 72 | 90 | .444 | 14 | .245 | 14th | 4.33 | 8th | Wildcard | Lost in LCS |
| . | 2011 | Oxen | Kim Hoffman | 65 | 97 | .401 | 26 | .000 | -- | 0.00 | -- | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2012 | Oxen | Kim Hoffman | 66 | 96 | .407 | 29 | .000 | -- | 0.00 | -- | n/a | n/a |
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | Totals | 1484 | 1540 | .491 | 4 Division Titles | 3 Championships | |||||||
| . | 4 Wildcards | 3 LCS Titles | |||||||||||
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | Taylors Tornados | ||||||||||||
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | Year | Team | Manager | W | L | Pct | GB | BA | Rk | ERA | Rk | Titles | Playoffs |
| . | 1993 | Rockets | Bruce Barber | 32 | 64 | .333 | 35 | n/a | - | n/a | - | n/a | n/a |
| . | 1994 | Crackers | Bruce Barber | 86 | 76 | .531 | ---- | n/a | - | n/a | - | Division Crown | Lost World Series |
| . | 1995 | Crackers | Bruce Barber | 71 | 91 | .438 | 24 | .263 | 11th | 4.64 | 10th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 1996 | Sting | Bruce Barber | 83 | 79 | .512 | ---- | .277 | 3rd | 4.41 | 8th | Division Crown | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 1997 | Sting | Bruce Barber | 81 | 81 | .500 | 11 | .255 | 15th | 4.45 | 10th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 1998 | Sting | Bruce Barber | 85 | 77 | .525 | 2 | .257 | 11th | 4.18 | 8th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 1999 | Sting | Bruce Barber | 76 | 78 | .494 | 22 | n/a | - | n/a | - | Wildcard | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 2000 | Sting | Bruce Barber | 85 | 77 | .525 | 5 | .266 | 15th | 4.55 | 3rd | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2001 | Sting | Bruce Barber | 94 | 68 | .580 | ---- | .272 | 9th | 4.73 | 7th | Division Crown | Won World Series |
| . | 2002 | Daisy Cutters | Chris Keleher | 67 | 95 | .414 | 27 | .253 | 13th | 5.50 | 14th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2003 | Capones | Brian LeBeck | 50 | 112 | .309 | 60 | .248 | 11th | 5.55 | 15th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2004 | Capones | Brian LeBeck | 51 | 57 | .472 | 24 | .244 | 15th | 4.51 | 7th | Wildcard | Lost in LCS |
| . | 2005 | Capones | Brian LeBeck | 87 | 75 | .537 | 8 | .256 | 12th | 4.31 | 4th | Wildcard | Won World Series |
| . | 2006 | Capones | Brian LeBeck | 56 | 106 | .346 | 38 | ? | ? | ? | ? | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2007 | Capones | Brian LeBeck | 83 | 79 | .512 | 15 | .274 | 2nd | 4.46 | 8th | Wildcard | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 2008 | Capones | Brian LeBeck | 92 | 70 | .568 | 6 | .261 | 8th | 4.04 | 5th | Wildcard | Lost in LCS |
| . | 2009 | Capones | Brian LeBeck | 64 | 98 | .395 | 23 | .256 | 8th | 4.88 | 12th | n/a | n/a |
| . | 2010 | Capones | Brian LeBeck | 86 | 76 | .531 | ---- | .273 | 5th | 4.58 | 9th | Division Crown | Lost World Series |
| . | 2011 | Tornados | Scott Blaha | 82 | 80 | .506 | 9 | .000 | -- | 0.00 | -- | Wildcard | Lost in 1st Round |
| . | 2012 | Tornados | Scott Blaha | 95 | 67 | .586 | ---- | .000 | -- | 0.00 | -- | Division Crown | Won World Series |
| . | |||||||||||||
| . | Totals | 1506 | 1606 | .484 | 5 Division Titles | 3 Championships | |||||||
| . | 6 Wildcards | 5 LCS Titles | |||||||||||